Choosing Strength Workouts: Dumbbells, Machines Or Bands?/ Newslooks/ WASHINGTON/ J. Mansour/ Morning Edition/ Strength training offers various methods, from free weights to machines, resistance bands, and bodyweight exercises. Experts explain how each option suits different goals, ages, and fitness levels. Beginners should start slow and seek guidance for safe, effective workouts.
Strength Training Options Quick Looks
- Free weights mimic daily life movements, boost stability.
- Weight machines are beginner-friendly and reduce injury risks.
- Resistance bands are portable, affordable, great for travel.
- Bodyweight exercises need minimal equipment, versatile anywhere.
- Experts recommend starting slow and seeking professional help.
- Variety in routines prevents boredom and improves results.
- All methods suit any age, paired with cardio workouts.
Deep Look
Experts Explain The Best Strength Training Methods For Your Goals And Lifestyle
When it comes to building strength, the choices can feel overwhelming: Should you grab a set of dumbbells, hop on a weight machine, stretch resistance bands, or stick with classic bodyweight exercises like pushups and squats?
According to fitness experts Dr. Rafael Escamilla, a biomechanist at Sacramento State University, and Dr. Michael Stone, a sports scientist at East Tennessee State University, the right choice depends on your age, experience, and personal goals. Both recommend consulting a doctor before starting a program, especially for beginners, and ideally working with a certified trainer initially.
Free Weights: Mimic Real-Life Movements
Free weights include dumbbells, barbells, kettlebells, and medicine balls. Stone calls them the top choice for most people because they mimic natural daily movements.
“If you’re relatively healthy, free weights are the way to go,” Stone said. “They have more carryover to daily life — lifting grandchildren, groceries — it transfers better.”
Free weights also engage stabilizing muscles, promoting better balance and overall strength. Beginners should start with light weights and increase gradually.
“I would also strongly suggest that if you’ve never lifted weights before, go find somebody who knows something about it,” Stone advised.
Weight Machines: Safe For Beginners
Weight machines can be less intimidating, offering fixed motions and stability for newcomers. They reduce injury risk and help beginners build confidence and familiarity with strength training.
“Machines are a good way to start,” Escamilla said. “They’re safe and easy and you don’t need a lot of technique or skill.”
Machines isolate specific muscles, making workouts efficient and targeted. Many people start with machines and transition later to free weights for added variety and challenge.
Resistance Bands: Affordable And Portable
Resistance bands and tubes are the go-to option for travelers or anyone with limited space. Lightweight, portable, and budget-friendly, they provide effective resistance for working various muscle groups.
“They take up no room to pack and they’re super cheap,” Escamilla said. “You can take them with you as you travel — just throw them in your suitcase.”
Bands come in different resistance levels and materials, including elastic and fabric options. While not ideal for heavy strength training, they’re excellent for the average adult looking to stay fit.
“The bands won’t cut it for a 300-pound football player,” Escamilla joked. “But they’re good for your average person.”
Bodyweight Exercises: Equipment-Free Strength
Bodyweight exercises like pushups, pullups, lunges, squats, and planks are timeless classics requiring little or no equipment. They’re versatile and effective for building strength and endurance anywhere — even at the beach or in a hotel room.
“Your body weight can be used as a form of resistance,” Escamilla explained. “You can get a good workout doing these and you need almost no equipment.”
Keep It Varied For Best Results
Regardless of your chosen method, variety is crucial. Repeating the same sets and reps can lead to plateaus and boredom. Change your exercises, weights, repetitions, or workout locations to keep things fresh and effective.
“You can’t do the same number of sets and repetitions all the time and expect to get better results,” Stone said. “You get stale and monotony can set in.”
Whether lifting weights, pulling resistance bands, or crushing pushups in your living room, the key is finding what works for you — and keeping it fun and sustainable. Strength training can fit into any lifestyle and help people of all ages stay strong, mobile, and healthy.
You must Register or Login to post a comment.