Former Justice David Souter, Republican Became Liberal, Dies at 85

Today at 9:55 am

3309 posts

Former Justice David Souter, Republican Became Liberal, Dies at 85/ Newslooks/ WASHINGTON/ J. Mansour/ Morning Edition/ Former Supreme Court Justice David Souter, once a conservative appointee who became a liberal favorite, has died at age 85. Known for his intellect and humility, Souter left a lasting mark on abortion rights and civil liberties. He passed away Thursday at his home in New Hampshire.

FILE – In this Dec. 5, 2003 file photo, U.S. Supreme Court Associate Justice David Souter poses during a group portrait session with the members of the U.S. Supreme Court, at the Supreme Court Building in Washington. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File)

Remembering Justice David Souter Quick Looks

Retired Justice David Souter died Thursday at age 85 in New Hampshire.
Appointed by George H.W. Bush in 1990, he served nearly 20 years.
Became a liberal-leaning voice on abortion, religion, and free speech.
Helped preserve abortion rights in the pivotal 1992 Casey ruling.
Lived a modest life; avoided Washington social scenes.
Continued hearing federal cases for over a decade post-retirement.
Worked long hours; known for his intellect and integrity.
Held a deep reverence for democracy and civic education.
Served previously as New Hampshire attorney general and state judge.
Remembered as humble, thoughtful, and fiercely independent.

FILE – In this Sept. 16, 2009 file photo, retired Supreme Court Justice David Souter works with his group to promote civics education in New Hampshire schools during a meeting in Concord, N.H. (AP Photo/Jim Cole, FILE)

Former Justice David Souter, Republican Became Liberal, Dies at 85

Deep Look

Former Supreme Court Justice David Souter, Unexpected Liberal Icon, Dies at 85

WASHINGTON — Retired U.S. Supreme Court Justice David H. Souter, a reserved New Englander and conservative appointee who became one of the high court’s most consistently liberal voices, died Thursday at the age of 85. The Supreme Court confirmed his passing at his home in New Hampshire in a statement released Friday.

Souter’s two-decade tenure on the court defied expectations from the start. Appointed in 1990 by Republican President George H.W. Bush, Souter was initially embraced by conservatives who hoped he would tilt the court rightward. Instead, he became a pivotal vote in landmark decisions supporting abortion rights, the separation of church and state, and expanded access to federal courts.

His defining moment came in 1992 with Planned Parenthood v. Casey, in which he joined Justices Sandra Day O’Connor and Anthony Kennedy in reaffirming the core principles of Roe v. Wade, preserving abortion rights for a generation. Though conservatives would later dismantle that precedent, Souter’s role in preserving it became central to his legacy.

In retirement, Souter warned against civic ignorance as a threat to democracy. “When problems get bad enough… someone will come forward and say, ‘Give me total power,’” he said in 2012, drawing parallels to the fall of the Roman republic. It was one of the few times the intensely private justice publicly discussed political anxieties.

A Life of Service and Simplicity

Souter was known for his frugal lifestyle, solitary habits, and deep love for the New Hampshire mountains where he spent his summers. He never married, never owned a smartphone, and dined daily on yogurt and an apple at his office desk. His primary joy was hiking—he would trek alone through the White Mountains each summer after the Court recessed.

Colleagues and court staff admired him not only for his intellectual rigor but also for his warmth, humility, and legendary storytelling. Chief Justice John Roberts said Souter brought “uncommon wisdom and kindness to a lifetime of public service,” noting that he continued to hear cases on the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals long after retiring from the high court in 2009.

From New Hampshire to the Nation’s Highest Court

Born in Massachusetts in 1939 but raised in Weare, New Hampshire, David Hackett Souter attended Harvard University, earned a Rhodes Scholarship to Oxford, and completed his law degree at Harvard Law School. After a brief stint in private practice, he served as assistant attorney general and then New Hampshire’s attorney general before becoming a judge on the state’s superior and supreme courts.

In 1990, Souter had served only four months as a federal appellate judge when President Bush nominated him to replace Justice William Brennan. His minimal federal judicial record prompted some to call him a “stealth nominee.”

Conservatives initially praised the appointment. Former New Hampshire Governor John Sununu, then White House chief of staff, called it a “home run.” But Souter quickly disappointed the right, notably in the Casey decision and a ruling upholding bans on public school-sponsored prayer.

His votes and legal reasoning often aligned with liberal justices, though he was no ideologue. In a 2008 case involving ExxonMobil and the Exxon Valdez oil spill, Souter sided with the company in reducing punitive damages, parting ways with his usual liberal colleagues. Biographer Tinsley Yarbrough noted Souter “did not take extreme positions” and often sought pragmatic legal outcomes.

A Justice of Quiet Conviction

Known for his piercing questions during oral arguments, Souter was described as having a “knack for identifying the weakest link” in legal reasoning, according to Supreme Court advocate Carter Phillips. He maintained a rigid work ethic, often working 12-hour days, seven days a week, from October through June.

Despite being hailed by The Washington Post as Washington’s “most eligible bachelor,” Souter had little interest in the city’s social life.

“I wasn’t that kind of person before I moved to Washington, and, at this age, I don’t see any reason to change,” he once told an acquaintance.

After retiring, he purchased a home in Hopkinton, New Hampshire, reportedly due to fears that the book-laden foundation of his farmhouse in Weare might collapse under the weight of his collection. He spent his days reading, writing, and reflecting in near anonymity.

An Enduring Legacy

Though he never sought the spotlight, David Souter’s legacy is one of principled independence and quiet devotion to justice. His votes helped shape decades of constitutional law, while his humility stood in stark contrast to the growing politicization of the Supreme Court.

In a time of heightened ideological battles, Souter remained true to a judicial philosophy rooted in precedent, reason, and restraint. He was, above all, a justice who let his conscience—and the Constitution—guide his decisions.