New Pope Leo XIV Embraced as Midwest Everyman \ Newslooks \ Washington DC \ Mary Sidiqi \ Evening Edition \ The ascension of Pope Leo XIV, formerly Robert Prevost of Chicago, has triggered a wave of American pop culture enthusiasm, with many projecting Midwest “everyman” qualities onto the new pope. From sports cards to sandwiches, the U.S. has embraced him as both holy leader and relatable figure. But experts warn that this desire for familiarity may mask the reality of his global role.
Quick Looks
- Fake Videos and Memes Emerge: Viral content portrays the pope as a relatable Midwesterner.
- Pop Culture Reacts: Topps issued a baseball card; Portillo’s named a sandwich in his honor.
- American Humor Takes Over: Jokes about deep-dish communion and collection baskets accepting Kohl’s cash spread online.
- Cultural Projection at Play: Experts say Americans have long sought to humanize power figures.
- ‘Regular Guy’ Pope Image Spreads: Despite global responsibility, Pope Leo XIV is cast as “the pope next door.”
- U.S. History of Anti-Elite Identity: From Jackson to Reagan, Americans idolize leaders who appear accessible.
- Reality TV Roots: Sociologists say reality TV blurred lines between public figures and personal intimacy.
- Experts Caution Boundaries: Familiarity can weaken moral authority and religious influence.
Deep Look
By midweek, it became unmistakably clear: America had found a new pop culture obsession, and it wasn’t just about religion. It was about relatability. As Robert Prevost, a Chicago-born cleric, officially became Pope Leo XIV, Americans began reimagining the supreme pontiff of the Roman Catholic Church as something far more personal: a guy who might tailgate at a White Sox game, drink Midwestern craft beer, or casually accept Kohl’s Cash at Sunday Mass.
The memes and fake videos came first. One viral clip claimed a woman was recounting her “situationship” with Prevost before he donned the papal robes. Others surfaced showing him allegedly opining on Chicago beef sandwiches vs. hot dogs or debating NBA trades in a classic Midwestern accent.
Portillo’s, a beloved Chicago-based eatery, released a tongue-in-cheek tribute sandwich described as:
“A divinely seasoned Italian beef, baptized in gravy, finished with the holy trinity of peppers.”
Even Topps, the baseball card company, joined the frenzy, issuing a Pope Leo XIV card already being resold on eBay.
The Pope as a Symbol of “Just Like Us”
This blend of holy reverence and Midwestern informality taps into a deeply American instinct — one shaped by the country’s founding values and complicated relationship with power. Historian John Baick calls it part of a long tradition where Americans elevate leaders while insisting they remain grounded.
“Popes have always seemed distant, alien, above it all. But Leo XIV? He’s from the Midwest. That makes him one of us,” Baick says.
Indeed, Americans seem to take comfort in imagining the most powerful religious figure in the world as someone who might sit across from them at a diner on a Sunday morning, hum along to Bruce Springsteen, or cheer for the Sox from the bleachers.
A Nation That Rejects Royalty but Craves Relatability
This paradox — rejecting monarchy but craving familiarity with power — has shaped American identity since the nation’s birth. According to David Gibson, director of the Center on Religion and Culture at Fordham University:
“We want people to look up to, but also sit down with. That’s the American contradiction.”
From Abraham Lincoln’s log cabin mythology to George W. Bush’s beer-buddy persona, the ideal American leader is often sold as down-to-earth. Bill Clinton played sax on late-night TV. Ronald Reagan delivered fireside charm. Barack Obama shared his March Madness brackets. Even Donald Trump, despite his billionaire brand, branded himself as a man of the people.
The Pop Culture Machinery Behind the Papacy
Sociologist Danielle Lindemann, author of True Story: What Reality TV Says About Us, points out that America’s obsession with “ordinary people made extraordinary” is a byproduct of modern media.
“We’re conditioned to relate to powerful figures on a personal level,” Lindemann says. “Reality TV has created a culture where public figures are expected to be both aspirational and approachable.”
By flooding the internet with details about Pope Leo XIV’s Chicago roots, Midwestern upbringing, and relatable quirks, Americans have forged an emotional proximity to someone who technically resides in Vatican City, leads 1.4 billion Catholics, and oversees a 2,000-year-old institution.
But the Pope Is Not Your Friend
Still, experts caution that relatability has its risks. When sacred figures are humanized too much, their ability to command spiritual authority can erode.
“The pope is not your friend. He’s not going to have a beer with you,” Gibson says. “If you think he’s your pal, what happens when he challenges your lifestyle or reminds you of your duties as a Catholic?”
The church, he warns, seeks to connect—but also to guide, rebuke, and remind its followers of difficult truths. When leaders are viewed through the lens of pop culture, their moral credibility can be diluted by the familiarity of celebrity.
More Than a Viral Moment
In reality, Pope Leo XIV is far more complex than his American mythos suggests. Fluent in multiple languages, including Spanish, he spent two decades in Peru, where he earned dual citizenship and took part in pastoral and administrative duties. A video of him singing “Feliz Navidad” at a holiday event recently surfaced—another glimpse into a rich life well beyond Midwest clichés.
And yet, it’s telling that his Chicago roots are what many Americans cling to. In a fractured age of political distrust and spiritual uncertainty, perhaps the desire for a “pope next door” reflects a yearning for guidance that feels both divine and deeply human.
A Pope, a Nation, and a Mirror
The story of Pope Leo XIV is not just about a man who rose from the streets of Chicago to the Vatican. It’s about a culture that seeks to see itself in those it elevates, a nation that prizes humility in power, and a people who, even when facing eternity, still want to talk about sandwiches and sports.
You must Register or Login to post a comment.