Utah Protest Shooting Leaves Organizer Dead, Gunman Arrested \ Newslooks \ Washington DC \ Mary Sidiqi \ Evening Edition \ A protest safety volunteer fatally shot a bystander while firing at an alleged gunman at a “No Kings” rally in Salt Lake City. Arturo Gamboa, arrested for creating the threat, allegedly brandished a rifle but did not fire. Authorities are investigating whether the safety volunteer’s response was justified.
Quick Looks
- A safety volunteer fatally shot protester Arthur Folasa Ah Loo while aiming at alleged gunman Arturo Gamboa.
- Gamboa, who carried a rifle but didn’t fire, was arrested for inciting the deadly incident.
- The shooting occurred during a large, peaceful anti-Trump “No Kings” protest in Salt Lake City.
- Investigators are reviewing video footage and seeking public help to clarify the events.
- Utah’s open-carry laws complicate assessments of legal versus threatening behavior at public protests.
- The shooter, a military veteran and rally safety volunteer, is under investigation but hasn’t been named.
- Ah Loo, a beloved fashion designer and former “Project Runway” contestant, was killed in the chaos.
- Protest organizers discouraged bringing weapons; police say the permit didn’t mention armed security.
Deep Look
The fatal shooting at Salt Lake City’s “No Kings” protest has become a flashpoint for broader national debates around gun rights, protest safety, and the blurred lines between threat, defense, and tragic miscalculation. On a day meant to showcase resistance to authoritarianism—symbolized by President Donald Trump’s controversial military parade in Washington—violence erupted in Utah, underscoring just how volatile public demonstrations can become in an era of open-carry laws and deeply polarized politics.
What began as a peaceful gathering of nearly 18,000 protesters quickly devolved into chaos when a safety volunteer, charged with protecting demonstrators, opened fire on a man alleged to have brandished a rifle near the crowd. The intended target, 24-year-old Arturo Gamboa, was hit—but so was 39-year-old Arthur Folasa Ah Loo, a respected fashion designer and community leader who was simply participating in the protest.
Ah Loo was rushed to a hospital but later died from his injuries. Gamboa was treated for a relatively minor wound and was arrested on suspicion of murder. According to police, Gamboa had not fired his rifle, raising immediate questions about whether the safety volunteer was justified in shooting. The volunteer, a military veteran, has not been named publicly, and as of now, faces no charges. However, Salt Lake County prosecutors have confirmed that both his actions and Gamboa’s behavior are under active investigation.
Authorities are now asking the public for any video footage of the incident to better reconstruct what happened in those critical seconds. Investigators are trying to determine whether Gamboa posed an immediate threat and whether the safety volunteer’s use of deadly force was legally permissible under Utah’s self-defense laws. A state judge granted an extension to keep Gamboa in custody without bail until Monday as evidence continues to be reviewed.
The incident has ignited debate over the presence of firearms at protests, particularly among those designated to ensure crowd safety. The “No Kings” protest was organized in part by the 50501 Movement, which has chapters across the U.S. Organizers said in a statement that the safety volunteer was part of a team composed of military veterans and first responders trained in de-escalation tactics—not violence. Yet, the organization also admitted it had instructed all volunteers not to carry weapons, raising further questions about whether the shooter violated organizational protocols or misunderstood his role.
The Salt Lake City police have said that the event permit made no mention of armed security, and they are now examining whether the presence of a gun-wielding safety marshal was unauthorized. Experts in crowd control and protest safety have stressed that marshals are meant to de-escalate tension—not escalate it with firearms. Edward Maguire, a criminology professor at Arizona State University, called the use of armed peacekeepers “dangerous,” noting that “arming marshals tends to create more problems than it solves.”
Indeed, the tragedy illustrates the high-stakes complexity of open-carry laws in protest scenarios. Utah is an open-carry state, meaning that individuals legally permitted to own a firearm can carry it openly in public spaces, including protest sites. While such laws are designed to preserve Second Amendment rights, they can also foster fear and confusion—especially in emotionally charged environments where distinguishing between legal gun ownership and an imminent threat can be impossible in the moment.
Law professor Timothy Zick of William & Mary explains: “In a chaotic protest space, it’s nearly impossible to sort out who is acting lawfully with a firearm and who is posing a real danger. This is the inevitable risk of allowing openly armed individuals to mix with large crowds.”
That risk materialized tragically for Arthur Ah Loo, known to many in the community as “Afa.” A former Project Runway contestant and beloved figure in Utah’s creative circles, Ah Loo was not only a fashion designer but also a cultural advocate, dedicated to uplifting artists from Pacific Islander backgrounds. He had called Utah home for over a decade, after emigrating from Samoa, and was widely respected for his generosity and leadership.
A GoFundMe page for his family noted that he leaves behind a wife and two young children. State Rep. Verona Mauga, a friend and fellow Samoan, described him as “a light for his people” and “someone who always chose to build bridges, not burn them.” Friends say Ah Loo was preparing for a major fashion show in August that will now serve as a memorial in his honor.
In the aftermath, public trust has been shaken—not just in the safety of public gatherings, but in the systems meant to protect them. Protest organizers now face pressure to clarify their policies on armed volunteers. Lawmakers may soon be asked to revisit how open-carry rights intersect with public safety at mass events. The tragedy also deepens ongoing national scrutiny over how armed civilians—including those with the best intentions—can unintentionally escalate situations.
As Salt Lake City mourns, the investigation into this deadly chain of events remains underway. For now, the memory of Arthur Ah Loo looms over a protest that aimed to challenge power with peace—but ended with yet another reminder of how fragile that peace can be.
Utah Protest Shooting Utah Protest Shooting Utah Protest Shooting
You must Register or Login to post a comment.